Trendy. Timeless.

Totally affordable

polymer clay earrings.

A pair of earrings displayed on a gold stand with a minimalist white and gold design.

At Klay Baybay, every pair of polymer clay earrings is a work of art—crafted with intention, detail, and style. Chic, versatile, and lightweight, our designs bring high-end style to your everyday look without the high-end price tag. From coffee dates to cocktail hours, you’ll find artistry and sophistication in every pair.

SHOP NOW

The Essentials Collection

Timeless. Versatile. Effortlessly chic.

The Essentials Collection was designed to move beyond novelty and into fashion-forward style. Handcrafted from lightweight polymer clay, each piece pairs minimalist design with modern sophistication—made to complement every outfit. These are the earrings you’ll reach for again and again: understated enough for everyday, yet striking enough to make a statement.

The Valentina The Valentina The Valentina The Valentina The Valentina The Valentina
The Valentina
$17.00
The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline The Madeline
The Madeline
$17.00
The Taylor The Taylor The Taylor The Taylor The Taylor The Taylor
The Taylor
$17.00
SHOP THE WHOLE COLLECTION

Reviews

  • These earrings are GORGEOUS! Kimmie outdid herself with the detail! I’m always so happy with my orders, shipping was fast, and Kimmie is a joy to communicate with. Looking forward to the next drop!

    Darby L

  • Kimmie makes awesome earrings! I have well over 300 pairs 😳 I recommend her to everyone, you too will be hooked 😊

    Debra C

  • Every pair of earrings I have bought are sooooo cute and hold up well. I also have sensitive ears, so I love that she has surgical steel options!!!

    Carissa B

  • Kimmie makes the CUTEST handmade earrings. I love wearing them because a lot of earrings actually irritate my ears after only a short time. But never Klay Baybay earrings! They’re extremely light weight and never cause any irritation. Check out her website or find her at the local market Item

    Taylor S

  • I couldn’t speak anymore highly of this small business. Kimmie’s work is absolutely TO DIE FOR!! It’s all so cute! As a fellow clay artist I love what she does! I hope more and more people come to find her page because she deserves it all ❤ If you ever need a cute, seasonal pair of earrings go see her for all your earrings needs!

    Kaia P

  • Got the cutest pumpkin stud earrings. Not only are they high quality but they are also super cute and I have received many compliments on them.

    Hannah E

  • Kimmie makes such cute earrings! If you ever see me wearing earrings, 90% of the time, they're something from Klay BayBay! She's so creative and takes such care to create earrings people will love. Highly recommend!

    Bonnie K

  • I have SO MANY PAIRS of Klay Baybay earrings!! Seriously. My fiancé is making me a special earring holder for them all because I have no self control. These earrings are awesome quality and they’re SO stinkin’ cute. Every single pair. I get compliments on them every time I wear them. Buy all her earrings, you’ll be exceptionally glad you did.

    Ronni M

  • Love these earrings! So cute and there are so many types and shapes! I love all the earrings I’ve bought! Kimmie is awesome! I suggest everyone to check her out!

    Debbie C